Best Pizza in Irvington

Where Every Customer Is Family

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Arugula and Shaved Parmesan Salad (Small)

Red onions, roasted peppers, tomato and oil and vinegar dressing

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken with mozzarella cheese

Chicken Scarpariello Pizza

Large. Pan pizza only. Chicken breast, sausage, pepperoncini peppers, rosemary and brown sauce

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Grilled. Chicken and BBQ sauce

Chicken Francese

Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

This place has some of the best pizza and fries I have ever had. He has the best chicken roll and garlic knots I have ever had. Great prices, and has deals for students. Delivery is very fast and staff are very nice and friendly.

Eric L.

Eric L.

Great place with hardworking friendly people especially the owner who is incredibly nice. Great food and experiences overall.

Prank B.

Prank B.

Best pizza around. Nicest guy owns this little shop. Great garlic knots, homemade mozzarella squares the best. Everything I've ever had from here is spot on

Bonnie P.

Bonnie P.

Love the BBQ chicken with Mac and cheese

David D.

David D.

Amazing and great food for a fair price, very friendly owner and a great place to get a to-go pizza from. I recommend the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza or the Buffalo chicken pizza for new comers. An easy and cheap place for students.

Chaeil Y.

Chaeil Y.

The pizza was great! Super fresh and flavorful. The staff was really welcoming as well.

Naomi C.

Naomi C.

Featuring

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we're famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best.

Made With Love

Made With Love
Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be — from start to finish.

Order via Slice

Order via Slice
Order your favorites through Slice!
Order Slice
Tony's Pizzeria Rewards

Tony's Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Come and Try Us!

Come and Try Us!
Best locally-owned independent Italian restaurant in Irvington, New York serving my real, authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Get the best Italian restaurant near you! Every dish is made with love and care to give you a great tasting and unique experience every time. Come taste the difference.

Frequently asked questions

Our location